scientificflair: (Your early ending was all wrong)
Jean Descole ([personal profile] scientificflair) wrote2012-05-23 05:31 am

005. Audio.

[Those just turning their Gears on to check the Network this morning will be greeted by strains of music over Descole's feed - something melancholy, being played on violin; the song is something he'd heard many times before over the course of his...stay in Misthallery, and he understands that it's likely in horrible taste for him to be playing it at all, but it's a rather pretty song regardless.

After a while, the melody pauses, though there are a few notes being played lightly in the background, long and drawn-out; the sound appears to have shifted some, as though the violin has been adjusted away from the Gear.]


In a setup to a puzzle that's been around for a while, you meet three men in a wood, at a fork in the road. A sign above them states that one man is God; he knows all, and always tells the truth.

One is the Devil; he likewise knows all, but always lies.

The third man is ambiguous; he knows nothing, but will answer as though he knows everything. His answers are completely useless, and could be either right or wrong.

The sign states that you are to ask the men one question each - three questions total - that can be answered with "yes" or "no," with the intention of determining which person is whom. Were this a proper puzzle, I'd be asking you what question you would ask to which man.

[His hand shifts a bit on the violin, idly trilling the notes a bit while he thinks.]

However, when faced with the possibility that one of the men before you always lies...how are you to know that the Devil didn't post the sign in the first place?

[And with that, the melody seems to pick up again; the feed keeps going for about another minute or so before cutting off.]
brilliantideas: (☢ 12)

[personal profile] brilliantideas 2012-05-23 07:42 pm (UTC)(link)
Ah, yes, I can see where it would be. A bit of a stretch, that is. Yes, it's something we're programmed to feel. Testing is... well, it's like an itch. Only actually having an itch is a different feeling, really, but that's the only way I know how to describe it. Ah, that's not the point. Right. Well, it's this need to test. Oh it's very enjoyable when it's done right! But when it's not done right it's... ah, hmm. I'm not quite sure how to describe it. It's unsatisfying? Something along those lines.

But when the tests are performed correctly...! Ah, it's a glorious feeling! A simulated one, but I really can't tell the difference between genuine and simulated, so I suppose that doesn't matter all that much.
meatysoviet: (not entirely trusting)

[Audio]

[personal profile] meatysoviet 2012-05-23 08:13 pm (UTC)(link)
... All actions can rouse suspicion.

[His voice indicates that he thought that was really rather obvious.]

This very riddle could be seen as suspicious, if looked at in certain ways.
enjoymyatelier: maybe he should check the foundations, come to think of it. (red car. good point.)

[audio]

[personal profile] enjoymyatelier 2012-05-23 09:36 pm (UTC)(link)
Technically, there was nothing keeping it from being a lateral thinking puzzle in the first place. There's more than one way to solve it as it is.
thetruehistorian: (sidelong glance)

[personal profile] thetruehistorian 2012-05-23 10:06 pm (UTC)(link)
It is my experience that those in the business of lying will tell you the truth at first, so that you'll easier believe the lie when it is told.
milquetoasthero: (39. belt out a song)

[audio]

[personal profile] milquetoasthero 2012-05-24 12:27 am (UTC)(link)
[No sense in doing anything halfway, right?]

They have no reason to doubt otherwise. And if you're at a fork in the wood, then I think you'd want to get out as soon as possible, so I bet it doesn't really cross your mind.
booze: (don't waste my time)

[Audio]

[personal profile] booze 2012-05-24 02:52 am (UTC)(link)
[oh hello did you call for someone to ruin this post

well too bad because Xanxus is messing this shit up]


What the fuck kind of bullshit is this?
usedfeatherdance: (Not sure if want)

[voice]

[personal profile] usedfeatherdance 2012-05-24 02:00 pm (UTC)(link)
I didn't know they made violins here.

[ This is much more relevant to his interests than your word puzzle. ]
icansolvethemtoo: (pondering...)

[voice]

[personal profile] icansolvethemtoo 2012-05-24 02:51 pm (UTC)(link)
...that's a very difficult puzzle.

[But she's getting that eerie feeling that it's not so much as puzzle as it is some dark statement on matters she doesn't quite understand. But on the off chance that it is a puzzle, she's going to think about it.]
thetruehistorian: (one piece)

[personal profile] thetruehistorian 2012-05-25 05:12 pm (UTC)(link)
I'd imagine we do more often than we know. But we continue on our own path, without bothering to stop and speak with the three men. In that case, does their existence even matter?
booze: (the hell do you want)

[Audio]

[personal profile] booze 2012-05-25 05:12 pm (UTC)(link)
Like I'm going to waste my time on a stupid fucking puzzle like that one.

[It's ambiguous enough as it is; is it really necessary to make it even more complicated? Fuck that noise.

Although, he's kind of curious now...]


You're from Layton's world, aren't you.
3_butterflies: (Shuffle-Step One Two.)

audio

[personal profile] 3_butterflies 2012-05-25 05:16 pm (UTC)(link)
Oh, no. They can't talk like we do. Only a few like myself can understand them.
3_butterflies: (Default)

audio

[personal profile] 3_butterflies 2012-05-25 05:20 pm (UTC)(link)
Mmm! The animals here are different, but I can still understand them, and they're all wonderful. I want to be friends with all the Pokemon!
booze: (i know you're there)

[Audio]

[personal profile] booze 2012-05-25 05:20 pm (UTC)(link)
[Figures. The people from Layton's world are the only ones who make such a big fucking deal about puzzles. It's sad that he can distinguish them so easily like that.]

I met him about a year ago and he's hardly left me the fuck alone since.

[Of course, what he's failing to mention here is that he actually kind of likes Layton's company.]

Page 6 of 7